Sometimes the most loving thing you can do is set them free…
I've been seeing a really specific dynamic more and more in my work with couples over the past couple of years: one partner has already left the relationship emotionally, they've thought about separation, imagined what life might look like on the other side of the marriage. And they know they don't want things to continue as they are and sometimes they know they don't want the relationship at all.
But they're waiting….
I see them waiting for their partner to initiate the conversation or for the spouse to finally do something that makes leaving feel “justified”. Or even waiting for things to get bad enough that the decision is made for them.
So often I see someone holing the knowledge that they don’t want the relationship anymore….but they're hoping their partner will be the one to end the marriage.
And it’s such an injustice, it’s so unfair to everyone involved. So we need to talk about why this is happening.
To state the obvious: ending a relationship is hard.
Even when you know it's the right decision, there's grief, guilt, uncertainty, and the very real knowledge that you're about to hurt someone who may still love you deeply and for whom you might have some positive regard.
That’s all great and noble…but I most often see people struggling with taking ownership of a decision that will fundamentally change another person's life. Honestly, I see a lot of people ultimately decide they’re simply unwilling to make that decision.
For some people, it's easier to wait until their partner gives them a “reason” to leave. Because if their spouse becomes distant, angry, unkind, or eventually files for divorce, they no longer have to carry the weight of being the person who ended things. They can tell themselves, and perhaps others, that they didn't have a choice.
But so often, this waiting comes at a significant cost to the person on the other side.
You cannot continue asking someone to invest in a relationship that you already know you no longer want to participate in.
Think about what that experience might be like for the other. They may still be trying or they might be interpreting your withdrawal as a rough patch, believing that if they can just figure out what's wrong, things might get better. Maybe you’re showing up to couples therapy together and they’re initiating conversations, making changes, or desperately trying to reconnect.
Meanwhile, you've already checked out.
That's a painful imbalance.
And it’s dishonest.
And while you may tell yourself that you're protecting them by not initiating a difficult conversation, you may actually be prolonging their investment in something you've already decided you don't want.
To be clear, there’s a difference between being unsure about a relationship and knowing you want out but not wanting to be the person who says it.
Ambivalence deserves exploration. Sometimes, couples reach a point where one or both partners question whether the relationship can be repaired. Those conversations are important, and there is often meaningful work to be done before making a decision.
But when you've arrived at the conclusion that you no longer want to be in the relationship, and you continue to withdraw, create distance, or wait for your partner to make the decision for you isn't giving the relationship another chance. It's avoiding responsibility for your own decision and expecting someone else to figure it out for you.
And there's another consequence worth considering: this dynamic can make repairing the relationship nearly impossible.
Rebuilding a marriage requires two people who are showing up in good faith together.
I’ll often tell a couple inquiring about couples therapy with me that it’s only appropriate to get started if they’re willing to work and make changes. That doesn’t mean they’ll walk out of my office at the end of therapy choosing to be together forever…sometimes couples do hard work and decide together in the end to go their separate ways. But they’ve done that with a spit-shake agreement to stay engaged, do their part, and be honest.
So if one partner is silently waiting for the other to end things, they're not really participating in that process. They're not working toward reconnection, rebuilding trust, or creating something different together. They're waiting for an exit. And their partner may be spending considerable emotional energy trying to repair a relationship that isn't actually being offered the opportunity to heal.
Sometimes, that avoidance shows up in ways that are particularly damaging. Becoming increasingly critical. Withholding affection. Picking fights. Refusing to engage in meaningful conversations. Creating an environment in which your partner eventually becomes so unhappy that they are the ones to leave.
Whether intentional or not, you're essentially asking someone else to do the emotional labor of ending a relationship you've already decided to leave.
You are allowed to leave a relationship. You don't need your partner to be abusive, unfaithful, or objectively terrible to justify ending a marriage. You don't need a dramatic event or a sufficiently compelling reason that everyone around you agrees with. You are allowed to decide that you no longer want to be in the relationship.
But you do have a responsibility to be honest about that decision.
Because you made a commitment at some point in time to someone, you owe them the honesty of knowing whether you're still choosing that commitment.
Perhaps this is the part that deserves the most consideration: Your partner deserves the opportunity to be with someone who genuinely wants to be with them. They deserve to make decisions about their own future with accurate information. They deserve to stop trying to repair something that the other person has already decided they don't want.
Keeping someone in a relationship under the pretense that there is still a mutual desire to make it work is not kindness. Sometimes it's just a way of avoiding your own discomfort at their expense.
If you know you want to leave, have the courage to say so. Be willing to sit with the discomfort of knowing that your decision will hurt someone. You don't have to make them the villain to justify your choice, and you don't have to wait for them to give you permission to go.
Sometimes the most loving thing you can do for someone is stop asking them to keep choosing you when you've already stopped choosing them.
Sometimes setting someone free means having the courage to be the one who opens the door.
If you're struggling with uncertainty about your marriage, questioning whether to stay or leave, or trying to determine whether your relationship can be repaired, working with an experienced couples therapist can help you navigate those decisions with greater clarity. I work with couples in Franklin, TN, offering couples therapy focused on communication, emotional connection, relationship distress, and helping partners determine what comes next. Whether your goal is rebuilding your marriage or navigating a difficult decision about its future, you don't have to figure it out alone.